What Juicer Is The Best For Me?

If you are new to juicing or even if you have been juicing for awhile, you may have wondered at one time or another, what is the best juicer to buy? On this page we will be clearing up some of the confusion surrounding different types of juicers, will talk about our choices for the best juicers, and will help you to sift through all of the information that is out there. This should help you to make the best decision and get the most value for your money when purchasing your juicer.

In general there are three main categories that juicers fall into that make them different from one another. These are centrifugal juicers, masticating juicers (single gear juicers), and triturating Juicers (twin gear juicers). All of these juicer types have pros and cons. We will go through these in detail on this page so that you can make a better decision when selecting the best juicer for you to buy.

Centrifugal Type Juicers

Centrifugal juicers are more common and may beBest centrifugal juicer to buy the type of juicer that most people are generally familiar with. Centrifugal juicers usually have an upright design with a large chute or cylindrical chamber that you load your fruit and vegetables into.

Once loaded into the juicer a spinning blade grinds the plant material down and sends it against the walls of a mesh screen that is spinning at a high speed. The centrifugal force of the mesh screen then pulls the juice out of the pulp, filters it through and delivers it to you, usually through a spigot of some sort. The pulp is either left behind for you to clean out as you go, or in a lot of cases it is ejected out and you can place down a container to catch the pulp and then a separate container to collect the juice.>

Pros

  • One of the upsides of a centrifugal juicer is that they are faster than the other two types of juicers. If you are in general busier and need to juice quickly in order to have some on the go this can be helpful.
  • A centrifugal juicer can also handle bigger pieces of fruit and vegetables, which can make the preparation easier and more time effective.
  • In general centrifugal juicer are more affordable than masticating juicers and triturating juicers. This is not always the case, but the cheapest models available are usually the more commonplace centrifugal juicers.

Cons

  • One of the downsides of a centrifugal type juicer is that they are generally less efficient than a masticating juicer, or a triturating juicer type. This has been my experience as well as countless of other people. The pulp that comes out of a centrifugal type juicer is a lot wetter than that of a masticating type juicer or a triturating type juicer. This means that a centrifugal type juicer produces less juice in general. We can't speak to exactly how much less this is, but in general it has been shown to be less than the other types mentioned above. So the money you save from purchasing this type of juicer could in the long run be lost by the amount of juice left inside of the pulp.
  • Centrifugal type juicers are not as efficient when juicing leafy greens and in general cannot juice wheatgrass. This does not mean that they cannot juice leafy greens, it is just that they will not be nearly as efficient as a masticating juicer when it comes to this. A lot of people overcome this difficulty by rolling their leafy greens up into a tight sort of ball. This way they are more densely packed together, which seems to help the centrifugal juicers have an easier time.
  • Centrifugal juicers can only make juice. The other two types of juicers mentioned here can do more than just juice. This will be expanded upon more below.
  • Centrifugal type juicers are louder in general than the other two types of juicers. This is not the case with all of them, but it is the case in general. Reading reviews of the specific juicer you are looking into could help shed some light in this area when looking to make a decision on which one is right for you.
  • One of the main downsides associated with centrifugal juicer types is that the rapid rpm's they run at generate heat and also introduce air into the juice, causing oxidation. This can damage the nutrients, antioxidants, and enzymes in the juice. While you will still get a lot of the health benefits that the juice delivers. Your juices full potential may be diminished.

Conclusion For Centrifugal Type Juicers

If you are on a budget and/or are just wanting to give juicing a shot without making a larger financial commitment. A centrifugal juicer can save you a lot of time when it comes to the preparation and juicing of your fruit and vegetables, as well as money.

You will still get a lot of the health benefits of juicing using a centrifugal type juicer. The exact amounts of nutrients lost in the process of juicing while using these types of juicers has not been shown in great detail. Also, when speaking of nutrient loss many people are speaking about optimal values of nutrition, and of course you want to get as much out of your juice as possible. Rest assured, drinking fresh raw juices made by yourself in your own home made by almost any juicer is going to yield high amounts of vitamins, minerals, and many other nutrients that will be great for your health.

Drinking your own homemade juice from any juicer is much healthier than drinking store bought pasteurized juice that has been sitting on a shelf for who knows how long. The nutrient degradation that has occurred in shelf juices goes far beyond anything that takes place with fresh made juices that are consumed within a day or so of making them. Most of the nutrients that are found in packaged juices have been added back into them because they don't have many of their own left.

We tell a lot of people when they are trying to make a decision about the best juicer to buy is  that the best juicers for people are the ones that they will use. If a centrifugal juicer is what you can afford, then it is going to be a much better choice than not buying a juicer at all.

Another thing to consider is what kinds of produce are you going to be juicing more of? If you are not going to be juicing as many leafy greens as often and instead are looking for a juicer that can handle fruit and other vegetables, then a centrifugal juicer may be good for you. In the end the best juicer for you is the one that you will use more. If a centrifugal juicer will get you to do this then this juicer is a great choice for your health and well being.

Our Recommendations for the best centrifugal juicers! 

The Breville BJE200XL Compact Juice Fountain 700-Watt Juice Extractor saves counter space and is said to work just as well as many other larger juicers. It is also easier on the pocketbook and can be a great way to start your juicing journey! This is the juicer that we recommend to anyone who is on a budget and asks us what the best juicer for them to buy is.

This is the juicer that Joe Cross used in the movie "Fat Sick And Nearly Dead"! The Breville JE98XL Juice Fountain Plus 850-Watt Juice Extractor is also more affordable than other higher priced juicers and gets the job done! Many people use this juicer and are very happy with it. If you have not seen the movie "Fat Sick And Nearly Dead" you really should check it out. This movie really has begun a juicing revolution and is proof of the power of juicing for health. You can watch this movie completely free at hulu.com by following this link here. Fat Sick And Nearly Dead 

We have also written a post that covers the best budget juicers on the market. These are all centrifugal type juicers and you can read more by following the link provided.

Masticating Type Juicers

Masticating juicers use a single gear or auger to One of the Best Juicersliterally chew up the fiber of fruit and vegetables. The cell walls of the fruits or vegetables are broken down through a grinding motion. The juice is then squeezed and separated from the pulp by crushing the produce against a screen. The leftover pulp and the juice come out of the juicer through separate exits and can both be collected by containers or whatever means you wish to use.

Pros

  • One of the upsides of a Masticating type juicer is that they are able to juice just about any kind of fruit and vegetable. Masticating juicers can also handle juicing leafy greens as well as wheatgrass. This means you do not have to purchase a separate wheatgrass juicer if this is one of the things you would like to juice. This also means a much greater efficiency in juicing your leafy greens, which can make a huge difference in the long run.
  • Masticating type juicers in general extract juice more efficiently than that of a centrifugal type juicer. We have owned both types and this is something that we have definitely noticed. The pulp from the masticating juicer has been a lot drier and the amount of juice that we have gotten from many fruit and vegetables has been more. Many other people have this experience as well. There have been quite a few tests to demonstrate the efficiency of a mastication style juicer vs a centrifugal style juicer. There is one vegetable that seems to yield more in a centrifugal juicer than in a masticating juicer. These are carrots, and although there is not a huge difference in the yield I thought it would be notable to mention this here to provide you with as much information as possible. 
  • Masticating type juicers can also handle other tasks separate from juicing. Masticating juicers can make nut butter, baby food, and frozen deserts (We like to make a banana/strawberry frozen desert that tastes just like ice cream. So good!). They can also extrude pasta (you can make your own pasta), extrude the milk from soy or nut mixtures (you can make your own nut milk), act as a food processor that can chop you're favorite vegetables, and grind coffee as well. They are able to do this with different attachments that usually come with the juicer when you purchase them. 
  • The final, and to me one of the great benefits of a masticating type juicer, is the quality of the juice that comes out. The masticating type juicers do not heat up nearly as much as the centrifugal type juicers. The juice that comes out of a masticating juicer retains the precious nutrients, enzymes, and antioxidants of the produce. The juice also is oxidized a lot less than the juice from a centrifugal type juicer. The juice from a masticating juicer in general retains a high amount of the good stuff you are trying to get into your body.

Cons

  • One of the downsides to a masticating type juicer vs a centrifugal type juicer is the general price of one.  In general masticating juicers are more expensive and this could be a consideration if you are on a budget.The upside to spending more money up front on one of these juicers though is that you will be getting more juice out of your fruit and vegetables over time. This will obviously add up and make it a much better bargain in the long run, especially if you plan on juicing a lot.
  • The only other downside to a masticating type juicer vs a centrifugal type juicer is related to the time spent making your juice. In general it does take more time making your juice with a masticating juicer. You will need to take more time to prepare your produce when using a masticating juicer. There is usually a smaller feed chute for these type of juicers and also they work at a much lower rpm. You will need to cut your produce into pieces of the right size so it can fit into the feed chute. Masticating juicers use an auger to crush the juice vs a blade which rapidly cuts the produce apart in a centrifugal juicer. Many will agree that the extra time spent to prepare their produce is well worth it as you will be getting a better quality juice. This to me is what separates these two types of juicers the most.

Conclusion For Masticating Type Juicers

If you are looking to get more out of your fruit and vegetables and have it in your budget, then a masticating type juicer would be one of the best juicers to buy. Not only will your juices be more nutrient dense, but you will save a lot of money in the long run as this juicer will squeeze more juice out per item of produce. Also while it is true that a centrifugal type juicer is quicker when juicing most of the time, a lot of masticating juicers can make up for this extra time by being much easier and quicker to clean up after each use. Many say this puts them on a level playing field when comparing them for overall time spent juicing.

Another bonus with masticating type juicers is the variety of other functions that can be used for. If you are someone who would like to make nut milks, make your own fruit desserts, make your own pasta, have an extra food processor around, grind your own coffee, or make your own healthy baby food then this juicer could be best for you.  

A big factor to take into consideration when considering what is the  best juicer to buy is what juicer you will be using the most. If you are going to be juicing a decent amount of leafy greens then you will definitely want to consider a masticating or triturating type juicer over a centrifugal type juicer. Hands down these types of juicers produce more juice from leafy greens than a centrifugal juicer does. Also, if you are wanting to juice wheatgrass and do not want to have to purchase a separate juicer, then a masticating or triturating juicer will be the best juicer to buy for you.

A masticating juicer will give you a lot more of the health benefits, more juice per produce item in general, extra functions, and the ability to juice a wide variety of fruit and vegetables . If it is in your budget and you are serious about juicing, then a masticating juicer will be one of the best juicers you can buy. Other than the more expensive triturating juicers, masticating juicers are the top of the line.

Our Recommendations for the best masticating juicers!

 


We personally own the Omega J8005 Nutrition Center Single-Gear Commercial Masticating Juicer, Chrome and Black and this has been a great juicer for me. This juicer is incredibly solid and has been able to handle anything we have thrown in it! If you buy one brand new it also comes with a 10 year warranty on all parts and labor! Since we can attest personally to the value of this juicer, it is definitely one that we recommend.

 


The Omega VRT350 Heavy Duty Dual-Stage Vertical Single Auger Low Speed Juicer is a very popular juicer and is known for its ease of use and efficiency! This juicer has two stages which help it to extract as much juice as possible. First the juice is extracted by crushing your produce. After this the pulp is squeezed to get even more juice out of it! The vertical design saves counter space making this a great choice for people looking for a juicer that takes up less room. It also includes two different screens giving you the option to have less pulp in your juice or more pulp in your juice. As with all omega juicers it comes with a 10 year warranty on all parts and labor. These are just some of the benefits of this juicer and you can read more by following the link above and to the left.

Triturating Type Juicers

Triturating juicers are the cream of the crop Best Juicers To Buy The Green Starand are the top juicers to consider when looking for the best juicer to buy. They operate similar to masticating juicers by working at a much lower speed. Instead of one gear (auger) though, these juicers have two of them. Thefruit,  vegetables, or whatever you put into these juicers gets slowly crushed between the two gears. The slower motion of their gears is believed to help separate the juice from the pulp much more efficiently. This gives you much more of the nutrition that is in the produce and leaves a much drier pulp behind.

Pros

  • Triturating type juicers produce the highest quality juice out of all the juicer types. This is due to their lower speeds (rpm's) and dual gears (augers) which help to maximize the nutritional potential of the juice that is extracted.
  • Triturating juicers are known to produce the most juice per produce item in general so that you really get the most out of your money in the long run. 
  • Triturating juicers can also handle juicing just about anything you throw at them. This includes vegetables, fruit, wheat grass, sprouts, and any other produce item that you might want inside of a juice.
  • Most triturating juicers can also be used to make make nut butter, baby food, frozen deserts, extrude pasta, extrude the milk from soy or nut mixtures, act as a food processor that can chop you're favorite vegetables, and grind coffee as well just like a masticating juicer can.

Cons

  • The only two downsides associated with these types of juicers are that they are generally slower than centrifugal type juicers and are among the most expensive types of juicers. The reason that they cost the most is because they produce the highest quality of juice. If money is not a concern and you are serious about getting the optimal amount of nutritional benefits from your juice then a triturating juicer is the only way to go and would be the best juicer to buy.

Our Recommendations for the best triturating juicers!

If you are looking to get the most out of your produce the Green Star GSE-5000 Elite Jumbo Twin Gear Juice Extractor is the top of the line! This dual gear triturating juicer is known to extract higher amounts of juice allowing you to get the optimal amount out of your produce! A lot of juicing experts as well as raw foods experts who have been juicing for a long time feel that this is the best juicer on the market. If you have the budget and are looking for the best, then this is the juicer for you!

Comments

    • Sean Carey says

      Hello, You can use a vitamix to make your juices. The process will take you time more time though than using a juicer to make juices. If you cannot afford a juicer though and would like to enjoy juices yes you can definitely use your vitamix to make your juices.

      What you do is just blend your ingredients together and then you will want to strain them through something to get the juices seperated from the pulp. A lot of people will use nut bags, or a cheese cloth to do this with. I have even read an article where a person used a pair of tights to do this with! I have even heard of people using clean clothing to do this, including old unused t shirts and other stuff. These would be a lot harder to get all the juice though as they would not make an optimal filter. I personally would recomend the nut bag or cheese cloth route, but sometimes you got to do what you got to do. :)

      Basically you will pour your blended mix into the bag of your choice over a large bowl or container that the juice will end up in. You then squeeze the bag to get as much juice out as possible. The pulp will be left in the bag and you will get juice inside of your container!

      This would be an excellent way of being able to make juices for yourself if you cannot afford a separate juicer. During a juice cleanse I could definitely see this being a lot of hassle as you will be wanting to consume a lot of juice, but it all depends on the person. If you are looking to just add some juices to your diet then this should be a great way for you to do that! Hope this helps and happy juicing! ;)

  1. Kim says

    Is it a bad thing to eat some of the pulp? I make green monster smoothies with spinach and fruit and drink it without straining it. Would some of the other veggies not taste good with the pulp left in? Or is there another negative aspect of leaving the pulp in? 

    • Sean Carey says

      Hello Kim, There is nothing at all wrong with eating the pulp. It is just not the same as a juice. Smoothies and juices are two different things. If you are doing a "juice cleanse" like we talk about on the site, then you will want to actually drink juices only to get the maximum benefits.

      If you are just trying to get some more vegetables and fruits into your diet through smoothies or juices by enjoying them here and there then either is fine. The main difference being that with juices you are left without most of the insoluble fiber(a lot of people do not know there still is soluble fiber in juice). The insoluble fiber is what we know as "pulp".

      This leaves behind the juice which contain all of the nutrients in pure form. The nutrients in juice is immediately available for your body to absorb and use. Since you do not have all of that extra pulp, which takes up a lot of volume and leaves you feeling fuller. You can actually consume more of the vegetables and fruits in the form of juices usually than you can in smoothies. So in general you can get a whole lot more at one time with a juice than you can with a smoothie.

      Your body also does not have to expend the energy and time to break down all of that fiber to get to the nutrition. I mean in a smoothie you do release a lot of the juice, but all of that fiber is still there and your body will have to work to digest that.

      With smoothies you get all of the benefits of the nutrients inside of the vegetable and fruits plus all of the fiber. You can do a smoothie cleanse, but it just isn't the same as a juice cleanse. A big part of the benefits you get from a juice cleanse is the break your body and organs get from having to digest all of the food you put into it. That coupled with the nutrients being available immediately for your body really make juices effective.

      On a day to day basis though and if you are just looking to add some smoothies to your diet there are no negative aspects of leaving the pulp in that I am aware of. It is just like eating your vegetables and fruits, except they are all blended up for you so you can guzzle them down. As for flavor I imagine that is different for each person, but I do know that leafy greens and Broccoli can be a stronger flavor at first. I imagine this would be the same for people who just begin drinking stronger tasting leafy greens or broccoli in their smoothies. Again to each their own though.

      ;) Have a good day and if you have any other questions feel free to ask them!

    • Sean Carey says

      While it is true that juicers have come a long way and there are more efficient options available now days. Your Jack Lalanne Power Juicer will suffice and will do the job, yes.

  2. Allie says

    What do you think about the nutribullet? It is supposed to leave the pulp in. I am wanting to begin juicing and want to purchase the right one!

    • Sean Carey says

      While I have heard the nutribullet makes a great smoothie, it is not a juicer. There is a difference between a juicer and a blender/smoothie maker. One leaves all of the pulp in(basically blends the entire produce item) and this is what the nutribullet does. The other extracts the juice from the pulp of the produce item and leaves most of the pulp out(although most juicers cannot catch it all and do leave some pulp inside) and this is a juicer.

      Everything we talk about on this page refers to juicers, and all of our recipes are juice recipes. I am sure some of them would make decent smoothies though to.

      If you are wanting to begin juicing and not smoothie making, then you will want a juicer, unless you are willing to strain the pulp from your blender manually. The juicers we talk about on this page are in our opinion the best juicers to buy on the market. If you read through the page you will learn a whole lot more and hopefully will be able to determine which one best fits your needs.

      If you have any other questions Allie let us know, we are here to help. Happy juicing!

  3. Dorothea says

    I have the ninja its says it does juices? After reading this I am guessing this isn’t going to work. Where can I buy a nutbag? Thank you

    • says

      Hello Dorothea,

      You are correct that the ninja does not make juices, but makes smoothies. I have noticed a lot of the websites of blending type machines advertising that their machine will make juices that include the pulp. These are actually smoothies and not juices no matter how they word it.

      Smoothies are still great for people, but they are not the same as juice. I included a link below to a nut milk bag that has great reviews and at this very moment is on sale for %91 off!

      Nut Milk Bag- New & Improved!

      Glad to hear from you Dorothea and if you have any other questions let us know!

  4. mrsdmk says

    I had originally purchased a NutruBullet but at first I was looking at the Fusion Juicer. To make a long story shorter I ended up buying a Fusion Juicer off an EBay auction that arrived non working so I purchased a Hamilton Beach Big Mouth ( and boy, is it powerful), and sold the Nutribullet. After drinking my first full glass of juice ( cucumber,parsley,ginger,lemon,and asian pear) I felt more refreshed and less full as to when I had made “NutriBlasts”. I wish I had just gone with getting the juicer in the first place…but what matters is now I have one and its more just a pesonal preferance of what types of foods& drinks you want to make. I also have a half decent blender that is for smoothies/protein drinks…but its not a VitaMix or a Ninja but it does what I need it to. Either way I am trying to increase healthy eating & drinking…and thats really all thats important no matter how you do it.

    • says

      That sounds great! We are glad to hear that you have begun juicing, and yes the most important thing is that you are increasing your healthy eating as well as drinking! Always happy to hear from you and congratulations on taking further steps to better your health! :)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *